Guest Highlight
Guest Columnist Howard Geller, founder and Executive Director of the Southwest Energy Efficiency Project (SWEEP), discusses the prospects for Energy Efficiency in the Southwest.

Alliance to Save Energy Column
Learn about new DOE State Energy Program Resources.

State Updates
Legislative and Regulatory News from Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin.

RECA Report
Get the latest on the work of the Responsible Energy Codes Alliance (RECA).

The Alliance Wants to Hear from You!
Contact us with suggestions or comments.



Click here to subscribe to the State Energy Efficiency Policy Bulletin
View Archives

Energy Efficiency in the Southwest: Withering in the Desert or Soaring among the Peaks?
By Howard Geller

The southwest region— Arizona , Colorado , Nevada , New Mexico , and Utah —is the fastest growing region in the country with respect to population and energy demand. But high energy demand growth stresses energy supply infrastructure and increases the risk of power outages. It also increases the need for controversial new power plants and transmissions lines, increases air pollution, and increases water consumption. With tight natural gas supplies and high gas prices, utilities throughout the region are proposing a new round of coal-fired power plants. If they get built, these plants will spew out carbon dioxide and other pollutants, and consume large quantities of water, for decades to come.

Given these problems, southwest states should be aggressively pursuing greater energy efficiency. But this generally has not been the case. The southwest is a major coal and natural gas producing region, energy prices are relatively low, and energy policy tilts towards encouraging more energy supply rather than restraining demand. Also, the southwest region tends to be conservative politically, meaning considerable opposition to new regulations or taxes. In short, the prevailing attitude in the region has been “energy is cheap, and real men (and women) dig up coal, drill for gas, and build power plants.”

Energy waste is a cost (both economic and environmental) that the southwest can no longer afford. Businesses are increasingly recognizing that energy waste hurts their bottom line. Governments are also recognizing that they can no longer afford to waste energy in their own operations. Once they start looking, businesses, public sector entities, and households find many opportunities for cost-effective energy efficiency improvements in spite of their relatively low energy prices.

The southwest is starting to mine its energy efficiency resource. The market share for Energy Star new homes has reached 50% or greater in Las Vegas and Tucson , for example. A growing number of new homes are going beyond the minimum and exceeding Energy Star performance by 15% or more. Utility and state programs, and public-private partnerships, are playing a key role in supporting the construction of these Energy Star and “Energy Star +” homes.

A few utilities in the region are ramping up their energy efficiency programs. Utah Power, owned by PacifiCorp, is planning to spend around $20 million (about 2% of their revenues) on energy efficiency programs this year, twice what it spent last year. Utility programs are expanding in Nevada as well. Arizona and New Mexico have adopted new policies to increase energy efficiency in the public sector. And while utility energy efficiency programs are still very limited in Arizona and New Mexico , there are signs that this will change in the near future.

The picture is cloudier in Colorado . A few publicly-owned utilities are ramping up their energy efficiency efforts, but Xcel Energy, the largest investor-owned utility in Colorado , operates limited efficiency programs. Even worse, Xcel plans to phase out these programs at the same time it is proposing to build a 750 MW coal-fired power plant. Neither the “conservative” state legislature nor the state PUC seems to mind. The Colorado legislature has also refused to adopt a modest renewable energy standard.

Frustrated with the PUC and legislature, energy efficiency and renewable energy advocates in Colorado have filed various ballot initiatives including a combined renewable energy and energy efficiency standard. The standard requires utilities in the state to get 15% of their electricity from renewable sources and/or energy savings by 2014. If this ballot initiative moves forward, it will be an interesting summer and fall.

Last but not least, a southwest governor or two is starting to stir the energy efficiency pot. Gov. Bill Richardson (D-New Mexico) recently hosted an Energy Summit under the auspices of the Western Governors Association (WGA). There he and Gov. Schwarzenegger (R-California) proposed clean energy goals for the Western U.S., specifically to develop at least 30,000 MW of clean energy resources by 2015 and increasing the efficiency of energy use in the West 20% by 2020. The Richardson-Schwarzenegger proposal will be submitted as a resolution at the June WGA meeting.

So is energy efficiency withering in the desert or soaring among the Rocky Mountain peaks? My answer is a lot of the former, and a little but a growing amount of the latter. Energy efficiency is taking off in parts of the region. However, the southwest still has a long way to go before it approaches the level of program activity or energy efficiency implementation found in other leading regions.

Howard Geller is the founder and Executive Director of the Southwest Energy Efficiency Project (SWEEP) based in Boulder , CO. For more information on SWEEP and its work, see www.swenergy.org

Back to the Top

New DOE State Energy Program Resources
By Kate Offringa

In a move to strengthen and showcase its State Energy Program, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) launched a new website this month. Click here to view the new site.

The new site includes a database of over 1,000 state energy efficiency and renewable energy projects searchable by state and by topic.  Users of the site will also find a new database of state publications.  This second database includes more than 500 titles on the topics of energy efficiency and renewable energy.

DOE's State Energy Program (SEP) is a federally funded formula share program, in which states must provide a 20 percent funding match (the program was appropriated $44.5 million in FY2004). States also may use Petroleum Violation Escrow (PVE) funds to implement activities under the State Energy Program. PVE funds date back to fees paid for oil price control violations in the 1970s.  PVE funds are distributed periodically based on Court decisions (settlements) and restitutionary claim procedures implemented by DOE, and are used to finance energy efficiency and renewable energy projects in the States. The last distribution- estimated at $7 million is expected early next year.

The success of these programs has been documented in a 2003 metrics report issued by the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL).  The report shows annual figures for State Energy Program dollar savings, energy savings and emissions reductions.  Annual energy savings attributed to the program equal 41 billion Btu.  The ORNL report is available by clicking here.

Back to the Top

 


Arizona
House Bill 2703 Transmitted to the House on 04/29/2004

HB 2703 would require the Department of Administration to develop and implement a program to enter into energy savings performance contracts. Each contract would be for a period of not more than fifteen years.

For more information click here

 

California
House Bill 2299 Referred to Committee on Natural Resources, Second Hearing Canceled at the Request of the Author on 04/19/2004

HB 2299 would require the California Energy Commission, not later than January 1, 2006 , to revise any regulation that was operative on January 1, 2004 relating to energy efficiency standards for commercial dishwashing pre-rinse spray valves. Starting on January 1, 2007 , the act would require every valve sold or installed in the state to use less than 1.6 gallons of water per minute.

For more information click here


House Bill 2541 Re-referred to Committee on Appropriations on 04/21/2004

HB 254 would require the Department of General Services, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board, to develop and implement a statewide Low Emission Contractor Incentive Program on or before July 1, 2005 . This program would apply to all state agencies and departments in contracting for construction, the procurement of goods, or the delivery of services.

For more information click here


House Bill 2652 Re-referred to Committee on Natural Resources on 04/20/2004

HB 2652 would require the California Energy Commission to establish a process of expedited review for projects for the re-powering of thermal power plants and give first priority to projects that demonstrate superior environmental or efficiency performance improvements.

For more information click here

 
House Bill 2924 Re-referred to Committee on Appropriations on 04/20/2004

HB 2924 would declare the intent of the Legislature, in subsequent legislation, to establish, increase, and modify incentives and to provide financing mechanisms for energy efficiency and photovoltaic capabilities for subsidized and affordable housing. This bill would also establish "zero energy homes" as a goal for low-income and first-time home buyers.

For more information click here


House Joint Resolution 50 Re-referred to Committee on Appropriations on 04/28/2004

HJR 50 would state California 's commitment to achieving a clean transportation future based on the rapid commercialization of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies, among other promising and complementary clean air and energy efficient technologies. The measure would also request the United States Department of Energy to recognize California's progress and commitment to accelerating the commercialization of hydrogen and fuel cell vehicles and to ensure that appropriate federal funding be provided to support those activities in California.

For more information click here


House Joint Resolution 74 Re-referred to Committee on Appropriations on 04/29/2004

HJR 74 would memorialize the President and the Congress to take legislative action to allow single-occupant hybrid electric vehicles that achieve a fuel economy highway rating of at least 45 miles per gallon, and conform to any additional emissions category of the federal Environmental Protection Agency or the California Air Resources Board, or meet any other requirements identified by the responsible agency, to travel in California's High Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) lanes.

For more information click here


Senate Bill 1565 Read Third time, Passed Senate and is now in Assembly on 04/22/2004

SB 1565 would require the California Energy Commission to adopt a strategic plan for the state's electric transmission grid to identify and implement investments needed to ensure reliability and to meet future growth in load and generation, including, renewable resources, energy efficiency, and other demand reduction measures. This bill would require the strategic plan to be included in the integrated energy policy report adopted on November 1, 2005 .

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Colorado
Senate Bill 168 Considered House Amendments on 05/03/2004

SB 168 would authorize the creation of renewable energy cooperatives to promote electric energy efficiency technologies and to generate, transmit, and sell electricity from renewable resources and technologies at wholesale. This bill also would allow the Colorado agricultural development authority and the Colorado housing and finance authority to issue revenue bonds to construct renewable energy generation facilities and electric transmission lines to facilitate the transmission of electricity generated by cooperatives.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Connecticut
Senate Bill 218 Tabled for Senate Calendar on 04/29/2004

SB 218 would extend the sales tax exemptions to July 1, 2008, for new motor vehicles including: vehicles exclusively powered by clean alternative fuels, conversion equipment that convert vehicles to the exclusive use of clean alternative fuels, or dual use of such fuel and any other fuel, equipment associated with compressed natural gas filling or electric recharging stations, and high mileage motor vehicles.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Hawaii
House Bill 2049 Passed in the House on 02/27/04, Passed in the Senate on 04/15/2004, and Passed out of Conference Committee on 04/30/2004 (Companion Bill SB 2470)

HB 2049 would increase the allowable length of energy performance contracts from 15 years to 20 years. This bill also broadens the financing options, amends definitions, and replaces shared savings plans with guaranteed savings plans.

For more information click here


Senate Bill 2474 Received Notice of Appointment of House Conferees on 04/21/2004 (Companion Bill HB 2965)

SB 2474 requires electric utilities to meet a renewable portfolio standard of 15 per cent for 2015 and a goal of 20 per cent for 2020. This bill directs PUC to study the feasibility of implementing a rate structure to encourage the use of renewable energy. The bill also requires DBEDT and DLNR to support and facilitate achievement of the renewable portfolio standards.

For more information click here

Back to the Top



Maine
Senate Bill 790 Signed into law on 4/14/04

SB 790 repeals the current single-family residential building insulation standards and amends the commercial, institutional and multifamily building energy standards to be in compliance with the 2003 International Energy Conservation Code.

For more information click here

Back to the Top




Massachusetts
House Bill 631 Reportedly favorably from the Energy Committee on 4/06/04

HB 631 would authorize the division of energy to establish a program to encourage the use of energy efficient appliances by consumers. The program would provide consumers with an exemption from the sales tax for purchases at retail of clothes washers, refrigerators or dishwashers which meet or exceed applicable energy saving efficiency requirements developed by the United States Department of Energy for the Energy Star program.

For more information click here


House Bill 4647 Introduced and Referred to the House Committee on House Steering and Policy on4/08/04

HB 4647 would require that energy efficient activities that are currently funded by mandatory charges per kilowatt hour, to also include a program that provides consumers with rebates equal to five percent of the purchase price of all Energy Star clothes washers, refrigerators or dishwashers.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Minnesota
Senate Bill 3046 Introduced and Referred to the Committee on Environment and Natural Resources on 04/22/04

SB 3046 would require Minnesota to adopt rules which are identical to the California air emissions reduction standards (chapter 200) for the cost-effective reduction of greenhouse gas emissions from motor vehicles. The rules would be effective for the 2009 model year and any model year thereafter.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Missouri
Senate Bill 1370 Adopted by Senate 4/08/04 and Referred to House Communications, Energy and Technology Committee on 4/27/04

SB 1370 would require any governmental unit of the state of Missouri, including any political subdivision, that enters into a contract for the implementation of any energy conservation or facility improvement measures to meet certain conditions.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

New York
Senate Bill 6502 Introduced on 3/16/04, Committee meeting held in the Senate Transportation Committee on 5/04/04

SB 6502 would permit hybrid vehicles to travel in high occupancy vehicle lanes regardless of the number of passengers in such vehicle.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Pennsylvania
House Resolution 681 Referred to the Environmental Resources and Energy Committee on 4/13/04

HR 681 urges the office of energy and technology development of the department of environmental protection to convene an energy summit to explore solutions to relieve Pennsylvanians from high home heating bills and to discuss options for addressing this problem in the long-term.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Tennessee
House Bill 181(companion to Senate Bill 266) Referred to the Rules Committee on 4/27/04

HB 181 would authorize governmental units to contract for training, new facilities, or facility alterations to reduce energy consumption. In order to enter a guaranteed energy cost savings contract, the governmental unit would have to request and evaluate proposals, determine that the cost of the energy savings measures would not exceed energy cost savings over a 10-year period, and issue a public notice of a meeting on the proposed award of a contract and hold such meeting.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Virginia
House Bill 887 Signed into law on 4/15/04

HB 887 exampts qualified hybrid vehicles from the motor vehicle emissions inspection program.

For more Information click here

Back to the Top

 

Washington
Senate bill 6146 Signed into law on 3/26/04

 SB 6146 encourages renewable energy and energy efficiency businesses in Washington. The Washington Technology Center (WTC) is directed to use its existing Northwest Energy Technology Collaborative Project to provide a forum for public and private collaborative initiatives to promote the renewable energy and energy efficiency sectors in Washington State and the Pacific Northwest. The WTC's responsibilities are amended to include using the collaborative project to develop and implement a strategic plan for public and private sector collaboration in renewable energy and energy efficiency business development.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

Wisconsin
Senate Bill 155 Signed into Law on 4/28/04

SB 155 directs the Department of Administration (DOA) to require state employees to utilize hybrid–electric vehicles or vehicles that operate on gasohol or alternative fuels for all state–owned or state–leased motor vehicles whenever such utilization is feasible. The bill also requires DOA to encourage use of hybrid–electric vehicles or vehicles that operate on gasohol or alternative fuel by officers or employees of this state who use personal motor vehicles on state business and by residents of Wisconsin state generally.

For more information click here

Back to the Top

 

The Responsible Energy Codes Alliance (RECA) continues its work to promote adoption of the International Energy Conservation Code (IECC). In April, RECA and its members were active in Arizona, Illinois, Indiana, Nebraska, New York, Maine, and Michigan. In Maine, thanks in part to the concerted effort of RECA members, the IECC 2004 code for commercial and multi-family state buildings is being implemented. Also, Senate bills 790b (LD1948) and 791b (LD 1949) were passed into law in Maine on April 14th, giving the PUC authority to alter the state residential energy code. States to watch for code developments in the month ahead are Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin.

Click here
to visit the RECA website for more information.

Additional Resources:

Building Codes Assistance Project (BCAP), a joint initiative of the Alliance to Save Energy, American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, and National Resources Defense Council, is dedicated to assisting states in the development and implementation of statewide building energy codes. For more information click here.

Appliance Standards Awareness Project (ASAP), a joint venture of the Alliance to Save Energy, American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, and the Natural Resources Defense Council, provides advice and technical support to parties interested in advancing state standards. ASAP is dedicated to increasing awareness of and support for appliance and equipment efficiency standards. For more information click here.

Back to the Top

 

Edited by Anna Carmichael, Policy Associate

This page was updated July 29, 2004
The Alliance to Save Energy
1200 18th Street, NW, Suite 900
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202/857-0666    Fax: 202/331-9588
policyinfo@ase.org                     www.ase.org